Swimming Pools: Alternatives to Chlorine

Chlorine keeps swimming pools safe and clean, but there are alternatives to chlorine if you're willing to pay the price.

I came across this article just at the right time.  I was talking to a friend who told me that there are many other alternatives to chlorine when it comes to treating swimming pools.  She went on to tell me how pleasant her experience was swimming in a pool without the chlorine smell or stinging eyes.  The timing could not have been any better!  Linda

Chlorine keeps swimming pools safe and clean, but there are alternatives to chlorine if you're willing to pay the price.

Chlorine is popular because it handles the three main jobs in keeping a swimming pool clean: It sanitizes (kills bacteria and germs), oxidizes (controls organic debris from perspiration and body oils), and deters algae. The chemical is unpopular because it has a strong odor, reddens eyes, and causes allergic reactions in some swimmers.

There are alternatives to chlorine including bromine, ionizers, and ozonators, though with each you'll still need to use some chlorine. A fourth alternative is PHMB, which doesn't require the use of any chlorine. All four have drawbacks, including cost.

Chlorine is relatively cheap. How much chlorine (http://www.ehow.com/way_5272184_much-chlorine-should-added-pool.html) you'll need depends on the size of your pool, length of the swim season, amount of use, and other factors. For a 20,000-gallon pool that's open year-round, figure you'll spend about $600 annually.

What it is: Pool suppliers sometimes suggest bromine as a substitute for chlorine. It can be an acceptable alternative for those with allergic reactions to chlorine, although that's not guaranteed since bromine is also in the same halogen chemical family. Aquatic specialist Alison Osinski believes 5% of the population has an allergy to chlorine.

How it works: Bromine does a fine job as a sanitizer, but it doesn't oxidize as well as chlorine. Most homeowners rely on a hybrid version known as BCDMH tablets that are typically 66% bromine and 27% chlorine to tackle that job. Some people opt for a two-step process of combining bromine salt extracted from seawater with potassium peroxymonosulfate (a.k.a. oxygen shock) in the pool to create that same sanitizing/oxidizing power.

Pros/Cons: Bromine remains stable at high temperatures, which is why many technicians recommend it for spas more than swimming pools. It's less irritating on mucus membranes than its chlorine cousin, although it still produces an odor. And if you use just bromine in the pool (not the BCDMH compound), it leaves the water a dull green color that foams up when you swim in it, because the oxidation process is weaker.

Cost: It's more expensive to operate a pool with bromine. Figure you could spend up to twice as much as you would if you use chlorine only.

What it is: Ionizers rely on two dissimilar metals--often copper (an algaecide) and silver (a sanitizer)--sent charged into the water as the sanitizer. The oxidizer is missing, so you'll need a small amount of chlorine or bromine in the water to handle this cleaning aspect.

How it works: An ionizer is a device that uses a low-voltage DC current to send these two metals into the water. The positive charge attracts bacteria, germs, and algae, and the new, larger compounds they form are carried out in the filtration system.

Pros/Cons: Like bromine, an ionizer doesn't irritate swimmers' eyes and noses. It can substantially reduce the amount of chlorine required. Chlorine and an ionizer work together better than chlorine alone, says Osinski.

Yet, she still considers ionizers a poor choice. For starters, you only reduce the chlorine amount significantly if just a few people use the pool on a regular basis, there are few plants and landscaping in the area, and your air isn't heavily polluted. High dirt levels are beyond what an ionizer can fight on the sanitation side.

Also, ionizers depend on moving water, so you must run the pool pump continuously to keep the sanitizing action in place. And the increased levels of metal in the water can stain the pool and turn swimmers' hair and fingernail beds green.

Cost: About $300 for an ionizer that handles up to 40,000 gallons of water. Homeowners may need to replace the metals in the system as often as once a swimming season, at an average cost of $129. Also factor in the energy cost of running the pool pump around the clock.

What it is: An ozonator is a machine that attaches to the filtration plumbing line. It inserts ozone gas (an active form of oxygen) into the pool to react with impurities in the water.

How it works: There are two types of ozone generators: ultraviolet light and corona discharge. In a UV light system, special low-pressure vapor lamps installed on the water return line create ozone to kill pathogens as they float by. Corona discharge generators rely on an electrical arc to create ozone inside the generator. Again, this ozone kills pathogens in the filtration system.

Pros/Cons: Ozone generators can reduce chlorine usage up to 90%, and they use the same amount of electricity as a 60-watt light bulb when the filter pump is turned on, so the added energy demand is tiny.

Aquatic consultants say ozonators combined with chlorine are extremely effective as long as you circulate the water 24/7. One caveat: Ozonators run best on dry air, so if you live in a humid climate, expect performance to decline.

Cost: A typical ozone generator starts at $600 to handle 7,000 gallons of water; $1,200 to cover 25,000 gallons. Take into account the expense of the pool pump running continuously.

What it is: There's only one way to eliminate the use of chlorine completely: Switch your pool to the chemical compound PHMB, short for polyhexamethylene biguanide. Homeowners commonly know PHMB by the Baquacil and SoftSwim brand names.

How it works: PHMB disinfects by penetrating bacteria cell walls, causing them to burst from within. It then wraps those particles in a heavy gel, which sinks to the bottom of the pool, where the vacuum system sucks it up.

Pros/Cons: PHMB doesn't oxidize, so you'll need to use hydrogen peroxide for this. You'll also need to use a separate algaecide and clean pool filters--yes, even the sand ones--every four to six weeks.

PHMB is kinder on swimmers' skin and hair, easy on vinyl pool liners, and doesn't require as much attention as other chemicals to keep in balance. However, because PHMB is incompatible with chlorine, you'll need to first drain the pool.

Once you're back up and running, make sure every bathing suit has been washed. Even traces of chlorine in suit fibers will react with PHMB. The result of the reaction: a yellowish vapor that'll radiate from your bathing suit.

Cost: The cost for PHMB chemicals to maintain a 10,000-gallon pool for a 16-week summer season is about $725.

By: Julie Sturgeon
Published: March 25, 2010
Julie Sturgeon has written about residential pools for nearly a decade. She has always used chlorine as her sanitizer because it's the path of least resistance.

Reprinted from House Logic with permission of the NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS®.  Copyright 2010.  All rights reserved.

I hope this information is helpful to you in finding alternative ways to keep your swimming pool in the "green."  Happy swimming!  Linda

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Dave Moeller June 19, 2012 at 11:48 AM
I have not heard of the PHMB solution but we switched to the mineral(salt)system. You use no chemicals,the salt does not evaporate so you only need to replenish what is drained or splashed. We spend about $200/yr for salt. The pool water ends up being about the same saline content as your body so it feels very natural, even when you open your eyes underwater. No allergies,red eyes,faded suits or green hair. The system is just about maintenance free.I am not sure how the chemistry works. Search it up there are a couple systems out there.The install is about $1500 equipment including the inital salt. 3rd year and no reqrets.
Warrior June 19, 2012 at 01:40 PM
I have been using baquacil for years and it doesn't cost $700.00 a year like the lady said. It costs me for a 8000 gallon pool approximately 250.00 a year. Also if you are using chlorine and want to switch to baquacil you do not have to drain your pool water. Baquacil sells a neutralizer solution to convert from chlorine to baquacil. Baquacil is so easy to use. Once a week I use 1 ounce of baquacil algecide. Every two weeks I use 3 cups of Baquacil sanotizer-algistat. And once a month I use 1 gallon of baquacil oxidizer. Hydrogen peroxide is not needed. Baquacil makes owning a pool so much more fun because you don't have to check your pool everyday like you do with chlorine. Ron
Linda Kemp June 19, 2012 at 03:22 PM
A big thank you to both Dave and Warrior! It is exciting to find that these green alternatives work well and aren't very complicated. So many people out there are just not aware that they have choices--choices that can affect their quality of life in a positive way. Thank you again for taking the time to share. Enjoy your pools and the summer months! Linda
Eric Dirst July 15, 2012 at 02:02 AM
I've heard of people also switching to salt water pools. I know overseas this is actually the more popular solution. I haven't met anyone yet who's switched. I myself still rely on chlorine. Anyone switched to salt water and have a story to tell?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »